Recommendation

Caution

Overall Summary

Suspicious

Why we think so

SubscribeStar.com is a platform where content creators earn steady income through subscriptions. It receives about 389,000 visits monthly, mainly from the U.S. It uses established payment methods like American Express, Visa, Apple Pay, and Gumroad, ensuring secure transactions. The website is hosted on reputable infrastructure providers such as CloudFlare, and its domain registration dates back to 2016, with valid SSL certification. However, user feedback frequently highlights poor customer service, difficulties with billing, and strict refund policies leading to financial misunderstandings. Despite these issues, there are no verified reports of fraudulent behavior directly by the platform, nor is it listed on scam blacklists. Overall, it is a legitimate service but with significant customer support and billing concerns that users should consider before subscribing.

Confidence Score

63%

Risk Insights

🛡️

Established Presence and Secure Infrastructure

Domain created in 2016 with valid SSL certificate.

Uses CloudFlare and trusted payment providers.

Nearly 400K monthly visitors mostly from the U.S.

⚠️

Customer Support and Refunds—Key Risks

Many user complaints about unresponsive customer service.

Strict refund policy favors creators, not subscribers.

Past removal by major payment processors increased payment complications.

Contradictory Signals

The platform is not flagged as malicious technically but suffers from poor customer experience and refund policies.

Signal A: No scam blacklist listings, safe domain status

Signal B: Numerous user complaints and billing disputes

Category Scores

Identity 65/100

Reputation 50/100

Technical 80/100

Content 55/100

Legal 60/100

Business Validity 70/100

Red Flags & Warnings

Recurring complaints about unresponsive customer support and billing issues that lead to financial loss for users.
Strict refund policies that do not cover undelivered content unless the creator reimburses subscribers directly.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Domain Age and SSL Validity

Score: 80/100

Passed

"Older domain registrations and valid SSL certificates reduce the likelihood of scam risk."

Reason: The domain was created in 2016 and has a valid SSL certificate, indicating an established and secure site.

Traffic Volume and Geography

Score: 70/100

Passed

"Legitimate websites typically have stable or growing visitor traffic from consistent geographies."

Reason: Substantial monthly visits (~389K), mostly from the U.S., indicate active use and legitimate audience.

Payment Infrastructure

Score: 70/100

Passed

"Use of trusted payment services supports legitimacy but does not guarantee user satisfaction."

Reason: Integration with major payment providers like Visa, Amex, Apple Pay, and Gumroad suggests proper payment handling.

User Reviews and Reputation

Score: 40/100

Failed

"Negative user experiences with customer service diminish platform reliability signals."

Reason: Frequent reports of poor support, billing errors, and refund difficulties create trust concerns.

Blacklist and Security Status

Score: 70/100

Passed

"Absence of blacklist status is necessary but not sufficient for full trust."

Reason: No listings found on known scam blacklists or Google Safe Browsing, indicating no detected malicious activity.

Trademark and Brand Authenticity

Score: 20/100

Passed

"Trademarks support brand authenticity but are not mandatory for legitimacy."

Reason: No trademarks found for SubscribeStar; common for some websites but slightly reduces brand trust signals.

Legal and Customer Disputes

Score: 50/100

Failed

"Policy and external payment issues impact consumer protection and risk."

Reason: Documented strict refund policies and past payment processor removals due to content controversy increase user risks.

Your Next Steps

1

If considering SubscribeStar, review its refund policy carefully to understand your rights and risks.
2

Avoid preloading funds or subscribing to creators without clear track records due to poor customer support.
3

Monitor your billing statements closely to catch unauthorized charges early.
4

Use payment methods that allow chargebacks or dispute resolution.
5

Consider reading recent user reviews on independent platforms before committing.

Evidence & Citations

SimilarTech Analysis for subscribestar.com
Technical profile and traffic statistics indicating a legitimate setup with popular payment methods.
Website Traffic Stats for subscribestar.com
User traffic data showing steady visitor numbers primarily from the U.S.
SubscribeStar Support and User Reviews
User reports highlighting poor support and billing problems causing financial complaints.
WHOIS and SSL Data for subscribestar.com
Domain has active registration since 2016 with valid SSL certificate.
Crypto Scam Sniffer Report
No blacklisting found against subscribestar.com.
USPTO Trademark Search
No trademarks registered for SubscribeStar found.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🌐 Scan another website

Run another instant due diligence scan on any website URL. Verify before you trust!

Review instant loan approval landing pages

Instant approval funnels promise same-day cash once you upload sensitive IDs, then resell the data or charge bogus fees....

Read playbook →

Review emergency disaster charity sites

Right after storms or earthquakes, scammers stand up donation pages that copy legitimate NGOs and push crypto wallets. S...

Read playbook →