Recommendation

Caution

Overall Summary

Suspicious

Why we think so

officesupply.com is an online retailer specializing in office supplies for businesses, schools, and homes. The site attracts about 628,000 monthly visits, mostly from the United States, ranking #65,571 globally and #13,281 in the US. It uses well-known infrastructure and payment technologies including Amazon hosting, PayPal, and Affirm. The domain is long established since 1998 and registered with Amazon Registrar, featuring valid SSL certification since May 2025. The company holds trademark registrations related to "officesupply.com" and operates contact channels including emails and phone numbers, plus social media accounts on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Pinterest. However, customer feedback reveals persistent issues with shipping accuracy, return policies, and customer service responsiveness, with multiple complaints across review platforms indicating problems such as wrong or incomplete orders, high return shipping costs, and unhelpful support. Despite these concerns, some customers report positive experiences with pricing and delivery speed. No current lawsuits or major legal disputes are reported, but terms of service enforce arbitration for claims over $75,000. Overall, while the website and operations appear legitimate and well-established, the company shows significant customer service and order fulfillment challenges that may affect buyer confidence.

Confidence Score

78%

Risk Insights

🕰️

Long-Established Domain and Brand

Domain registered in 1998 with continuous activity.

Active trademark registrations illustrate brand legitimacy.

Uses recognized hosting and payment technologies.

⚠️

Customer Service Issues Highlighted

Numerous complaints about incorrect shipments and returns.

Customer service often unresponsive or contradictory.

Return shipping costs burden customers heavily.

✅

No Technical Scam Flags

No detection in crypto scam or Google Safe Browsing blacklists.

Valid SSL certificate and reputable DNS hosting.

Technology stack uses known and trusted providers.

Contradictory Signals

While technical signals support authenticity, customer feedback reflects operational challenges affecting user trust.

Signal A: Technical indicators show a legitimate established business.

Signal B: Customer reviews report frequent service and fulfillment problems.

Category Scores

Identity 85/100

Reputation 30/100

Technical 90/100

Content 80/100

Legal 75/100

Business Validity 70/100

Red Flags & Warnings

Multiple customer complaints report incorrect shipments, missing items, and late deliveries.
Return policies impose high shipping costs on customers with limited company support, causing dissatisfaction.
Customer service described as unresponsive or rude, with contradictory information on cancellations and refunds.

🔎 Detailed Checks & Analysis

Domain Authenticity

Score: 85/100

Passed

"Domain DNS records and hosting are consistent with a legitimate business."

Reason: Established domain since 1998 with strong SSL, reputable hosting, and active AWS registrar.

Trademark Verification

Score: 80/100

Passed

"Trademarks have proper filings and ongoing maintenance reflecting established use."

Reason: Active trademarks related to OFFICESUPPLY.COM show legitimate brand ownership.

Technical Safety Checks

Score: 90/100

Passed

"The SSL certificate is valid; no phishing or malware signals found."

Reason: No blacklist detection from crypto scam or Google Safe Browsing databases.

Customer Service and Reputation

Score: 30/100

Failed

"Customer reviews indicate systemic problems with order accuracy and support responsiveness."

Reason: Many complaints about poor customer service, long waits, and refusal to resolve issues.

Business Validity and Legal Standing

Score: 70/100

Passed

"Legal framework exists but no high-profile disputes detected."

Reason: Company has formal dispute resolution clause and no known active lawsuits from public records.

Content Accuracy and Transparency

Score: 80/100

Passed

"Multiple verified contact points and social media presence support transparency."

Reason: Website provides clear product categories and contact information including email and phone.

Your Next Steps

1

Review detailed customer complaints on BBB and Trustpilot to assess risks before purchasing.
2

Consider ordering small quantities first to test service and fulfillment reliability.
3

Monitor for any updates on legal or scam reports over time to stay informed.

Evidence & Citations

OfficeSupply.com complaint and review summary
Numerous complaints on shipping, returns, and customer service noted by BBB reviewers.
Trademark registration for OFFICESUPPLY.COM
Trade mark for OFFICESUPPLY.COM active and maintained, supporting business authenticity.
SimilarTech profile for officesupply.com
Shows website technology stack, traffic data, and hosting details indicating a professional setup.
Google Safe Browsing status for officesupply.com
No phishing or malware warnings detected by Google Safe Browsing.

🕵🏻 Keep investigating

Recommended →

🌐 Scan another website

Run another instant due diligence scan on any website URL. Verify before you trust!

Review instant loan approval landing pages

Instant approval funnels promise same-day cash once you upload sensitive IDs, then resell the data or charge bogus fees....

Read playbook →

Evaluate investment webinar funnels

Webinars promise secret trading signals but quietly upsell unregistered brokers or payment wallets. ScamAI inspects regi...

Read playbook →